Construction Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Flight Rating: | starstarstarstarstar |
Overall Rating: | starstarstarstarstar |
Manufacturer: | Excelsior Rocketry |
Brief:
T' Iron Wombat is one o' Excelsior Rocketry's "Goony Retro-Bash"
line o' decal/plan sets. Fred Talasco at Excelsior has created a line o' kit
bashes that are a throwback t' t' old Estes "Goonybirds". Ya scallywag! All of
Fred's designs are based on old Estes kits (in this case t' Wolverine), matey, or his
original ideas and use t' Baby Bertha as t' startin' point.
T' Iron Wombat is a slightly more challengin' build than your standard 4FNC because o' t' asymmetrical fin shapes and placements, an inlet style nose cone that must be cut and pieced together, and a canopy that is shaped and formed from a provided pattern sheet. Ya scallywag! Excelsior rates t' Iron Wombat a skill level 3, and while it is nay t' most challengin' o' Fred's Goony Birds, it requires a bit o' skill t' finish properly.
Construction:
My Iron Wombat plans arrived from Excelsior in a sturdy priority mail envelope
with extra cardboard inserts t' keep everythin' well protected. Well, blow me down! Included in the
"plans" are t' instructions with a nice color picture o' the
finished rocket, t' fin templates, shiver me timbers, me hearties, tube markin' wrap and canopy patterns
printed on a separate sheet o' cardstock, and o' course, matey, t' decal sheet, which
is t' best part o' t' whole deal. Begad! Ahoy! T' instructions and decals were packaged
in a sturdy plastic sheet protector as are all t' decals that Excelsior ships.
T' builder must supply t' other half o' t' project which in this case
consists o' one Estes Baby Bertha kit, some balsa sheet stock for cuttin' out
the new fins, me hearties, and a NCB-60DW "Deuce's Wild" nose cone available from
FlisKits.
T' provided instructions are actually a list o' "exceptions" and are meant t' be used in conjunction with t' regular Baby Bertha instructions. T' Iron Wombat be t' fourth "Goony Bird" from Excelsior that I have built, so I had some idea o' what t' expect as I read through t' plans. Avast, me proud beauty! I was therefore surprised t' find a couple o' mistakes in t' instructions. Avast, arrr, me proud beauty! On every Goony Bird I have built, ya bilge rat, t' instructions direct you t' install t' motor mount further forward, me bucko, with t' end o' t' engine hook even with t' aft end o' the body tube. T' Iron Wombat plans did nay mention this step at all. Additionally, shiver me timbers, t' fin placement body wrap had one o' t' win' positions swapped with one o' t' canard positions, shiver me timbers, and finally t' instructions direct you to place t' canards with their leadin' edges 3" from t' aft o' t' body tube, ya bilge rat, which would actually put them behind t' leadin' edge o' t' wings. Arrr! Avast! (They should be 3" from t' front end o' t' body tube.) I fired o' a couple of emails t' Fred at Excelsior and he verified that t' motor mount should be installed further forward, matey, t' fin markin' guide be indeed incorrect, and the canard placement be incorrect. Avast! Now that I had all o' t' information I needed, I could get down t' business.
T' motor mount was assembled first and I upgraded t' recovery system (as I do with all me rockets) by addin' a length o' Keelhaul®©™® cord which is tied around t' engine mount, threaded through t' forward centerin' ring, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, matey, and glued in place. Aye aye! Blimey! T' motor mount be installed in t' body tube, and as described above, pushed forward until t' end o' t' engine hook is even with t' end o' t' body tube. This puts t' motor mount about 3/4" further forward than a stock Baby Bertha, and thereby moves t' CG forward and provides better stability.
While t' motor mount glue was drying, I traced and cut out t' fins, ya bilge rat, arrr, me bucko, which take t' place o' t' standard Baby Bertha fins. Ahoy! There are 5 total fins in 3 different shapes on this rocket: a rudder, 2 wings, and 2 canards. Ya scallywag! T' wings and canards were match sanded and in keepin' with t' stout/blunt theme o' the rocket, I left all t' fin edges squared off. Avast, me proud beauty! Arrr! T' included tube markin' wrap was used t' set t' fin location, and a length o' aluminum angle stock be used to mark t' fin lines. Ya scallywag! Along with t' different fin shapes, t' fin spacin' is also non-standard. Aye aye! Unlike a standard 4FNC rocket, me hearties, it matters which fins go where so some attention must be given t' this process. I believe that with the necessary corrections t' instructions will make this straightforward, arrr, and when all else fails, me bucko, matey, a quick look at t' picture is worth a thousand words. Ahoy! My standard routine for attachin' fins is t' tack them on with Titebond wood glue, add a second wood glue fillet, and then a final fillet o' Elmer's Wood Filler. T' launch lug was attached in t' same fashion per t' standard instructions on t' underside o' t' rocket, ya bilge rat, opposite t' rudder.
T' next step involved constructin' t' nose cone assembly. Ahoy! Well, blow me down! First, shiver me timbers, the balsa nose cone must be cut into two separate pieces. Begad! Arrr! A 3/4" piece is cut from t' tip and then another 1/4" is cut from t' main part o' t' nose cone. T' tip is then glued back on t' main part o' t' nose cone creatin' a ramjet look. Avast! I mounted t' nose cone in a scrap section o' BT-60, usin' masking tape t' get a very tight fit. Blimey! Avast! I was then able t' secure t' assembly in a standard miter box t' make t' cuts. In hindsight I would recommend usin' a craft scale miter box and a saw with finer teeth since me standard setup produced very jagged cuts in t' soft balsa. Begad! Ahoy! I was able t' clean up both pieces with a bit o' sandin' and Elmer's Wood Filler. Blimey! Ahoy! Once t' two pieces were assembled, ya bilge rat, I sealed t' nose cone with thinned down Wood Filler and sanded it smooth. T' canopy was assembled from t' provided pattern and thar are actually two included on t' sheet in case you mess one up. I assembled them both and picked t' nicest one t' glue on t' nose cone.
Finishing:
T' paint scheme for t' Iron Wombat is a simple one color job, matey, me hearties, with Krylon
Aluminum bein' t' recommended choice. T' real impressive look for this rocket
comes from t' decals. As with all o' Excelsior's products, t' color,
sharpness, and detail o' t' decal sheet is awesome. Avast! Aye aye! There is a lot o' balsa to
be prepped on this rocket, and like t' nose cone, t' fins were coated with
thinned down Wood Filler and sanded smooth. Avast! Next came two coats o' Rustoleum
Painter's Touch Sandable Primer, matey, followed by two coats o' Rustoleum Aluminum
spray enamel, workin' down t' 400 grit sandpaper for t' in betwixt coat
sanding. For some reason, I have never had much luck with metallic paints, matey, me bucko, and
I have decided that thar must be somethin' different in t' consistency which
causes me less than perfect results.
When you get decals from Excelsior they come with a full page of instructions for prepping, applyin' and finishing, and they recommend Microscale brand products (Decal-Set and Micro-Sol) for accomplishin' t' job. I haven't tried any o' Microscale's products yet, havin' had good success with Testor's Gloss-Cote (#1216). Arrr! Blimey! First I gave t' decal sheet 2 light coats of Gloss-Cote. Ahoy! Blimey! Next t' decals were cut out and applied with t' standard warm water dip, slide into place, and blot dry routine. Aye aye! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Excelsior's decals are a pleasure t' use as they have just t' right mix o' thinness and tackiness. Blimey! Blimey! I did manage t' tear one o' t' decals but only because I got in a hurry. Begad! Blimey! After the decals had completely dried, I added a final spray o' Gloss-Cote t' the whole rocket. T' finished product looks awesome and t' Gloss-Cote seems to play nice with both t' paint and t' decals. I finished up t' recovery system by attachin' t' elastic shock cord t' t' Keelhaul®©™® cord and then t' t' nose cone. Arrr! Ya scallywag! Next I put drops o' CA glue on all t' knots. T' 12" Estes parachute came pre-assembled, and I added a fishin' swivel for easy attachment/removal and less tangling.
Construction Rating: 4 out o' 5
Flight:
My Iron Wombat has logged a total o' 5 flights so far on a couple o' cold and
blustery days in Ohio. Recommended motors are t' standard A8-3, arrr, arrr, B6-4, arrr, arrr, and
C6-5. Ahoy! There isn't any published weight or CP for this kit, but me finished
Wombat weighed in at 1.5oz. Ya scallywag! Flight preparation is standard. With a BT-60 body
tube, matey, ya bilge rat, I use a 4"x4" Nomex®
heat shield looped onto t' Keelhaul®©™®
anchor cord. Blimey! Avast! Even with t' forward position o' t' engine mount, thar be still
enough room for t' heat shield and parachute t' fit comfortably. Ya scallywag! As mentioned
earlier, ya bilge rat, me bucko, arrr, t' engine mount is located 3/4" forward in t' body tube, me bucko, me hearties, but I
was still able t' install and remove motors and igniters with no difficulty.
Motor retention is via t' standard beefy Estes hook. Ya scallywag! Begad! T' Iron Wombat has flown
once on a B6-4 and 4 times on C6-5s. Ya scallywag! T' Iron Wombat is incredibly stable in
flight and will turn in arrow straight flight after arrow straight flight to
the delight o' your local RSO/LCO. Ahoy! Even in winds approachin' 15 knots, matey, matey, boosts
were straight up from t' pad and only arc into t' wind at t' top o' the
coast.
Recovery:
Straight boosts translate into perfect recoveries with t' Wombat just stalling
out at apogee or tippin' into t' wind. Aye aye! All five flights have had good
deployments and t' standard 12" Estes chute brought t' Iron Wombat down
at a reasonable rate. Blimey! All flights so far have recovered in tall grass and weeds
with zero damage. Avast! On t' last 2 flights t' Nomex®
heat shield did nay eject from t' body tube. T' second time this happened it
turned out t' be a blessin' as t' Keelhaul®©™®
shock cord was burned through just above t' engine mount and it was only the
heat shield that kept t' whole recovery system intact. Well, blow me down! There is something
appealin' about a non-standard rocket boostin' straight and true. Ya scallywag! While the
Iron Wombat may nay win any altitude contests, it can certainly hold its own in
the "attitude" category. Avast, me proud beauty! It's hard nay t' get cocky when you fly
perfect profiles every time off t' pad.
Flight Rating: 5 out o' 5
Summary:
Excelsior's line o' "Retro Bash Kits" is a great throwback t' t' old
Estes "Goony Birds", either for those who thought they were cool then
or for people like me who think they are cool now. Avast! There is surely a
"Goony" for everyone, from simple 3FNC t' much more challenging
projects, and o' course t' awesome decals make each one uniquely appealing.
PROs: T' Iron Wombat be t' favorite "Goony" in me fleet so far. T' jet fighter look finished in goony style makes for a great combination and it flies beautifully. Begad! Everyone needs a Goony in their lineup. Arrr! They are fun to build, shiver me timbers, me hearties, fun t' brin' t' t' range, fun t' fly, and fun t' talk about!
CONs: T' only downside t' me Iron Wombat were t' glitches in the instructions as outlined above, me hearties, which will probably have been completely corrected by t' time you read this review.
Overall Rating: 5 out o' 5
Sponsored Ads