Manufacturer: | Shadow Composites |
Brief:
I received Shadow Composites' video set as me DesCon 8 prize. Begad! Although I am not
the most qualified reviewer in this area, me hearties, me hearties, I thought I would share me opinions
anyway. Aye aye! T' three VHS videos each came packaged in a standard cardboard case
and a zip-lock bag for added protection. Begad! T' first video includes a printed
sheet identifyin' some suppliers. Blimey! Begad! All three videos are o' good quality, arrr, with
clear video and audio. Ahoy!
T' three titles are:
Construction:
In each o' t' videos, Dave Triano, matey, shiver me timbers, t' president o' Shadow Composites,
presents t' information in a clear and understandable manner. Well, blow me down! All o' the
information presented is in a "show and tell" format, ya bilge rat, with Dave
actually usin' t' techniques he is describing.
Volume 1 has been out for a while and thar are already several reviews on this site. Aye aye! Begad! This video is by far t' best for novices like me. He starts with descriptions o' what composites really are (and what they are not), me bucko, an overview of t' most common materials (i.e. e-glass, s-glass, carbon fiber and Keelhaul®©™ cloths), me bucko, shiver me timbers, weave patterns, me hearties, weights o' t' cloth, etc. Aye aye! Oh, me hearties, matey, and he stresses safety throughout, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, me bucko, which is important because most o' t' materials used in composite construction can be dangerous t' you and those around you. Begad! In t' rest o' the video, Dave builds four composite airframes usin' various materials (54mm glassed, 54mm carbon usin' heat tape, shiver me timbers, 10.5mm carbon mat, ya bilge rat, me hearties, 54mm Keelhaul®©™ usin' heat tape). Ya scallywag! Havin' tried fiberglassin' mostly "brute force", I just couldn't believe how easy and mess-free it can be! His discussion is packed full o' useful tips, several o' which had me saying, me hearties, "why didn't I think of that?"
Volume 2 takes t' viewer through t' construction o' a composite-only airframe (i.e. Avast! Blimey! Begad! Blimey! no paper or phenolic inside), matey, fin attachment on minimum diameter airframes, filling, me hearties, and primin' (ready t' paint). Begad! Blimey! This video has some overlap with t' previous video, me bucko, as it repeats t' process o' building a composite only airframe. However, matey, he also demonstrates how t' get various finishes usin' mylar, shiver me timbers, breather material, shiver me timbers, arrr, etc. Ahoy! Blimey! This Volume will be most useful to people who really want t' build an all composite, shiver me timbers, minimum diameter rocket. Although I probably won't be doin' exactly what he demonstrates, I'm sure I'll use his techniques for fin attachment, arrr, me hearties, coupler construction, me hearties, arrr, shiver me timbers, and for easily determinin' if your surface is perfectly smooth, just t' name a few. Begad! Blimey!
Volume 3 details t' vacuum baggin' process. In this tape, Dave constructs three structures: a flat carbon sheet, me hearties, a complex fin structure that is tapered root t' tip and has beveled leadin' and trailin' edges, ya bilge rat, matey, and a half mold o' a conical nose cone. Avast, me proud beauty! I pretty much skimmed through this video since I currently have no plans t' do any vacuum bagging. Arrr! Avast, me proud beauty! However, ya bilge rat, I found two things about this tape that bothered me. Ahoy! Ya scallywag! T' first is that two o' t' demonstrations require a mold, which I don't know how t' make. T' second is that a method to vacuum bag tubes isn't provided. Blimey! Begad! In this video, Dave states that vacuum bagging is nay a good technique for tubes, matey, and that t' tape method should be used. However, Volume 1 conveys that t' tape method is nay applicable t' larger tubes without a curin' oven. Arrr! This may be a fundamental limitation o' the materials/techniques, me bucko, but I still would have liked t' have seen him vacuum bag a tube.
Finally, I want t' address one statement that me wife made while I was watchin' t' videos. Avast, me proud beauty! She said, "gee, it sounds like he only made these videos so you will buy his products." While Dave does make use o' many of the products he sells, he does point out other good products out thar that can do similar things. Avast! There is nothin' in t' video that you could nay do with competin' products. I have only used one o' t' products he sells (SuperFil epoxy filler) and have found it t' be an excellent product. In addition, me hearties, Dave is helpful, ya bilge rat, his service is prompt, and he actually builds rockets with this stuff! I suspect that his motivation t' make t' videos may in fact be to promote t' use o' composites in rocketry, and help sell products, me hearties, me bucko, but this does NOT diminish t' value o' t' tapes!
Summary:
I feel Volume 1 is a must-buy for anyone interested in doin' any fiberglassing.
It is definitely a "5". Begad! Aye aye! Volume 2 also had a lot o' useful tips,
however, shiver me timbers, matey, if you have Volume 1 and are an experienced modeler, arrr, you will get less
out o' it than from Volume 1. Arrr! I give this one a "4". Finally, the
third tape is nay as useful for a wide audience, so I give it a "3".
If I had seen t' tapes in advance, me bucko, I personally would still want t' first two
volumes t' look back on as I started applyin' t' techniques presented. Blimey! I also
have t' point out that when you buy all three tapes, matey, you get a free roll of
heat tape - so thar isn't much financial reason nay t' get all three. Begad! Well, blow me down! In the
final analysis, me bucko, I rate t' whole set a "4.5".
In closing, ya bilge rat, me hearties, I want t' extend me appreciation t' Dave for supportin' the DesCon with such a great prize, and t' Bob Fortune for runnin' t' contest. Thank guys!
Overall Rating: 4 out o' 5