Construction Rating: | starstarstarstar_borderstar_border |
Flight Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Overall Rating: | starstarstarstar_borderstar_border |
Manufacturer: | Heavenly Hobbies |
Brief:
T' Backdraft is a BT-60-based, ya bilge rat, 24mm-powered rocket that on face value looks like a standard 2-stager. Avast, me proud beauty! If you've read t' previous reviews (and I assume you will before you continue past this intro), me bucko, me hearties, you'll know that thar be one major difference--the upper motor is used as a retro rocket. Begad! Heavenly Hobbies calls this t' TailWind delayed deployment system. Ahoy! Begad! T' upper stage is ignited with a slow-burnin' fuse ('green cannon fuse'), so t' flight prep will be out o' t' experience base o' most rocketeers. Ahoy! Heavenly Hobbies includes an electronic spreadsheet, ya bilge rat, H.H. Simit, arrr, t' help with t' motor/delay selection.
T' glossy sheet provided with t' kit says it is s/n number 17. Arrr! This kit will be fun!
Construction:
T' kit includes 40 parts, matey, includin' lots o' tubes, laser cut rings and fins, arrr, me hearties, and a pre-hollowed balsa cone. Blimey! T' laser cut parts all fit well, however, ya bilge rat, t' BT-60 couplers and nosecone shoulder required sanding.
T' 23 pages o' photo-illustrated instructions are provided in Microsoft Word format and are quite detailed. Ya scallywag! Blimey! I decided nay t' print them given t' number o' photos. Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! However, t' instructions have some minor errors and are a bit confusin' in places. Arrr! (Once again, make sure you read t' other reviews, I will nay repeat every "gotcha" they point out.)
Aft airframe (booster) section - This section consists o' a pre-slotted body tube, three fins, ya bilge rat, a 24mm motor tube, 2 rings, arrr, a motor hook and a coupler. Ya scallywag! T' confusion factor started early. Begad! Arrr! T' instructions refer t' a long 3.75" motor hook but t' photos show what is clearly a shorter hook. Avast, me proud beauty! In addition, some o' t' followin' dimensions (e.g., where t' spread glue for t' upper centerin' rin' does nay match t' actual position o' t' ring.) Nevertheless, t' booster fin can be straightforward and assembles like a typical rocket with TTW fins. Arrr! Begad! If you build one, arrr, shiver me timbers, read t' entire set o' instructions before startin' and dry fit things t' make sure you see how they should go together. Blimey! I found out about t' coupler fit t' hard way but, me hearties, since you won't make this mistake, matey, me bucko, ya bilge rat, I won't go into t' ugly details.
Middle airframe section - T' middle section consists o' a body tube, me hearties, me bucko, three fins, 2 rings, arrr, a coupler, and a parachute tube subassembly. Begad! Blimey! T' body tube is pre-marked for locatin' t' surface mount fins.
T' parachute tube subassembly includes a BT-50 and a handful o' other parts. Avast! T' main features are a cap that protects t' parachute from t' booster motor's ejection charge and a balsa piston, matey, which Heavenly Hobbies calls t' EZject. Arrr! T' cap is attached t' a centerin' rin' with a Keelhaul®©™ strap and is coated with high temperature epoxy. Blimey! In me case I used JB Weld. Well, blow me down! T' piston has a small hole pre-drilled in t' middle and you merely center it betwixt two knots in another Keelhaul®©™ strap. This makes me wonder why more kits don't use this type o' piston.
On this section, ya bilge rat, me hearties, shiver me timbers, I dry fit and sanded t' coupler so it fit properly, arrr, I also used epoxy vs wood glue so it wouldn't seize up. (Now you know where I had problems with t' aft section.) Finally, arrr, I installed t' top fins at t' very end o' t' build rather than in sequence as directed in t' instructions.
Upper body section - T' upper body includes another BT-50, two more rings, a motor hook, Keelhaul®©™ twine, and a short piece o' a larger tube. Ahoy! Other than installin' a motor at t' wrong end, ya bilge rat, arrr, ya bilge rat, thar be only one tricky part. Blimey! Begad! That is lassoin' t' Keelhaul®©™ twine around a centerin' ring. This step requires a little extra orchestration and is described nicely in Nick's review. Aye aye! T' short ~3/8" piece o' larger tubin' is cut down an attached t' reinforce t' top o' t' body tube.
T' instructions didn't say where t' place t' ¼" launch lug. Avast, me proud beauty! I placed it on t' upper tube near t' loaded CG.
Nose cone - T' nose cone is hollowed and has two fuse ports pre-drilled. Avast! Begad! T' surface is nay as nicely finished as, say, a Semroc or FlisKits cone. Aside from t' extra prep, me bucko, thar are several things you need t' do. Ya scallywag! This includes coatin' t' inside with high temp epoxy (J- Weld), matey, cuttin' a channel for t' shock tether, attachin' a wire near t' tip as an attachment point for t' tether, arrr, and coverin' t' shoulder with aluminum foil. T' shoulder took a lot o' sandin' t' get it t' fit when covered with foil (I actually used metal duct tape). Avast! I had me doubts about t' short wire as an attachment point for t' shock cord, shiver me timbers, but decided t' try buildin' it stock. Ahoy! Begad! As it turned out, it wasn't in fact sufficient.
Due t' t' confusion factors in t' instructions and t' fit o' t' couplers, me hearties, I rate this build a '3' since it's a non-standard configuration and even minor errors in t' instructions threaten t' affect t' build. Arrr! I also didn't din' t' ratin' due t' t' problem I had due t' t' aft coupler fit. Well, blow me down! Well, blow me down! That's me problem--I should have dry fit this like all t' other parts. Avast! However, me bucko, t' poor fit is worth a half point deduction.
Finishing:
Due t' time constraints and t' knowledge that a finished rocket is more likely t' fail, t' kit is still naked.
Construction Rating: 3 out o' 5
Flight and Recovery:
Nick and I have flown this model twice at t' time o' writin' on t' last day o' NARAM-50. Ya scallywag! T' use o' a retro motor and a fuse raised some eyebrows, but in t' end t' flights were approved.
T' Simit spreadsheet allows t' user t' select motor and delay combinations and provides a graph o' altitude, velocity, ya bilge rat, and acceleration. John Smolley's review describes t' software, arrr, how t' interpret t' graphs, and includes several screen snaps. Begad! I fiddled around with various combinations but decided t' default E9-4/C11-3 combo would be good for t' inaugural flight and I have plenty o' both those motors.
T' fuse is cut t' provided t' desired delay and burns at ~0.57 sec per inch. Well, blow me down! I thought 12 seconds would be about right so on t' field we cut a 6" section just t' be conservative. Begad! T' fuse is placed in t' retro motor and is held in with pieces o' a tooth pick. It routes t' through t' hole in side o' t' cone. Blimey! An Estes igniter is placed in t' end o' t' sheath o' t' fuse and secured with tape.
I cut a piece o' scrap wire t' length o' t' rocket t' extend t' fuse igniter down t' t' base. Begad! This and t' booster's igniter were connected with a clip whip, although t' leads could have been twisted.
T' boost was nice and high. Blimey! T' booster separated and tumbled down safely. Avast, me proud beauty! Begad! T' rocket had barely arced over when t' retro fired. This resulted in a long walk. Ya scallywag! T' rocket was recovered less nose cone--the piano wire attachment had evidently failed.
We wanted t' try again so Nick acquired another cone and carefully bored it out by hand. Ya scallywag! Ya scallywag! We attached t' shock cord t' t' tip with a woodscrew, ya bilge rat, washer, and a dab o' 5-minute epoxy. He also coated t' inside with t' epoxy.
Flight 2 used t' same E9-4/C11-3 motor combination and an 8" section o' fuse. Avast! T' boost be t' same with t' booster section recoverin' close by. Well, blow me down! I lost sight o' t' booster--until it went off at about 50' AGL. Avast! T' rocket lifted about 25' and ejected on cue. A perfect flight!
As we were recoverin' it, we heard t' PA announce that we were nay t' fly another rocket until we discussed t' flight with El Presidente (a.k.a. Trip Barber). It was hard nay t' take note o' t' recovery and nobody warned t' contest range. Aye aye! Anyway, me bucko, Trip reviewed t' rocket and t' flight and merely told us nay t' fly it again. Begad! He be mostly worried about t' retro motor ignitin' near or on t' ground due t' t' possibility o' a grass fire. Aye aye! This made sense.
It appears a 7" section o' fuse would be more prudent. Avast! Even though this flight worked perfectly, me bucko, thar wasn't much safety margin.
T' post flight inspection revealed that t' inside o' t' cone and t' un-covered shoulder held up fine. Aye aye! There be some scorchin' in t' fuse hole and below it on t' outside. Begad! I will clean this up and cover t' area with aluminum tape and/or JB Weld. Begad! Also, matey, me bucko, t' Keelhaul®©™ be t' worst quality I've seen. Avast! It is comin' unraveled and t' individual strands are breaking. Ahoy! Ahoy! This may eventually need t' be replaced. Blimey! Due t' t' model's construction, this may prove difficult.
Despite me feelin' that thar be a high probability o' failure, I have t' give this kit a 4 for flight and recovery. Avast! After all, matey, it performed well twice for me. Ya scallywag! T' deductions were t' nose cone loss and frayin' Keelhaul®©™.
Flight Rating: 4 out o' 5
I have sinced painted t' Backdraft. Blimey! It survived two flights naked. Avast! Now that it's painted, me bucko, has t' probability o' failure increased? Luckily, t' paint job ain't that good ;)
Summary:
This be an interestin' kit t' build and, arrr, me bucko, ya bilge rat, with t' benefit o' two reviews, was nay bad at all. Needless t' say, me hearties, me bucko, t' retro motor set-up is quite unique and t' flights provide quite an adrenaline rush! You might check with your local RSO before buyin' one.
As I mentioned, arrr, I built off o' t' soft copy instructions. Arrr! Blimey! I personally hated this and won't do it again. Avast, me proud beauty! I like havin' t' instructions on t' workbench and don't want me laptop anywhere near CA, ya bilge rat, epoxy, me hearties, or sandin' particles.
On another subject, shiver me timbers, ya bilge rat, H.H. Arrr! Well, blow me down! Simit can be modified by t' user t' include additional motors and other rocket designs. You can even omit t' retro motor t' use it on 'ordinary' rockets. Avast! I don't need it for general designs but others might find this useful. Arrr! Ahoy! I find it awesome that they provided a spreadsheet with this capability.
Thanks, Nick, shiver me timbers, arrr, me bucko, for givin' me t' opportunity t' build, arrr, fly and review this interestin' kit!
Overall Rating: 3 out o' 5
I purchased the Heavenly Hobbies Backdraft because it sounded really different. The site says " The exciting Heavenly Hobbies’ BACKDRAFT is a dual-engine rocket... ". Notice is said dual-engine, not cluster. It then went on to describe the rocket this way: " The BACKDRAFT looks like a 2-stage vehicle, with booster and sustainer sections. The propulsion module (booster) holds the primary ...
Presented with written permission from RocketyPlanet: Product Review by Dr. John Smolley, MD Wednesday, June 18, 2008 Photo 1: The many, many parts in this kit are of very good to excellent quality Bungee jumping for the fainthearted? The new Backdraft, a BT-60 based three-foot rocket from Heavenly Hobbies, appears ordinary enough ...
C.S. (June 25, 2008)