Construction Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Flight Rating: | starstarstarstarstar |
Overall Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Manufacturer: | U.S. Rockets |
Brief:
T' U.S. Rockets (USR) El Lubbo is unlike any other kit available. In an age
where cones and transitions are made o' plastic or balsa, an extremely
challengin' yet rewardin' build has come along where these items are made by
cuttin' and shapin' body tubes. Arrr! T' end result is a large yet extremely
lightweight mid power rocket that can be flown on most 29mm and 24mm motors.
Construction:
I ordered this kit along with 2 others directly from USR. They were ordered and
received without payment first. Arrr! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! When I received t' bill via email, shiver me timbers, me bucko, USR gave me
a discount on me order that resulted in a total amount (includin' shipping) for
less than t' cost o' t' 3 kits separately. Begad! Blimey! Both t' ordering/payment
arrangement and multi-kit discount are standard USR practices. Arrr! Blimey! Add in the
impressively fast turnaround time on email communications (responses in less
than one hour is in fact quite common!), and you realize that you are dealing
with a very customer driven business! Blimey! T' kits all showed up on me door in 2
boxes just a few days after havin' me order confirmed.
T' El Lubbo kit comes with t' parts loose in a box almost entirely dedicated t' shippin' (there be enough room t' safely squeeze in a USR Miniroc 1.2 kit with it). After verifyin' all parts were present and intact, me first reaction would have been "Where's t' nose cone? There's no balsa or plastic nose cone!" except I knew that t' kit has you buildin' t' nose cone and tail cone--the definitive elements o' this kit--from tubing. Begad! Blimey! You read that right. T' nose cone and tail cone are cut from tubing! Because o' the unusual and unfamiliar design o' this kit, I read through t' instructions. And then I read them again. Avast! While thar be enough material t' create 2 nose cones, there is only enough for one tail cone. T' room for error is small. I could tell that this be goin' t' be a challengin' build and one that would require a lot o' patience. Aye aye! However, arrr, if I followed everythin' t' t' letter, I would be rewarded for me efforts!
Also, because o' t' lightweight nature o' this kit, shiver me timbers, it is a good idea t' go easy on the glues and/or adhesives. Ya scallywag! USR recommends yellow wood glue (aliphatic resin) for t' build and I concur fully with that recommendation as it provides greater strength than t' materials bein' joined but without t' weight penalty of epoxy.
T' kit includes:
Aside from readin' t' instructions possibly a third or even fourth time, the first thin' that needs t' be done is t' clear out some "mental workspace" because you are goin' t' need t' forget a lot o' what you might normally want t' do when buildin' a rocket. Begad! Take several deep breaths and count to 10. Aye aye! Ready? Let's go then...
T' first couple steps are fairly conventional. Avast, me proud beauty! T' instructions have you round the leadin' and trailin' edges o' t' fins. My fins were all close but nay quite the same in shape though so I had t' match sand them. That didn't take long though since they are only (thick) balsa. Aye aye! Also seein' how this rocket is going to be a "slow and low" performer, me hearties, I chose t' only round t' leading edge so t' trailin' edge fin tips would be better suited t' handle any rough landings. Avast, me proud beauty! T' motor mount tube was then marked for t' fins and centering rings. Well, blow me down! All 6 items were glued and filleted one at a time in their appropriate locations on t' tube and then allowed t' dry.
Next you are informed t' read t' AIR-4 document before continuin' any further with t' build. Ya scallywag! This document explains t' how and why o' building custom shrouds from tubin' along with plenty of diagrams o' simple and complex shapes t' further demonstrate its point and simultaneously inspire t' builder (at least it did for me) for future builds as well. Arrr! Ahoy! Shrouds can be formed as nose cones, tail cones, ya bilge rat, or transitions. Ya scallywag! Avast! I will definitely be keepin' this document in a safe place for future reference. Well, blow me down!
With all o' that information absorbed, ya bilge rat, it's time t' return t' t' build. Ya scallywag! A "gotcha" makes its first appearance here. Ya scallywag! Begad! T' instructions have you use t' shroud markin' guide t' mark and cut t' tail cone shroud. If you do that first, me bucko, it will ruin t' nose cone markin' guide. Avast, me proud beauty! Instead, me hearties, refer t' all the instructional guidance on t' markin' guide sheet instead and start with the nose cone.
Now that trouble has been averted, you find out that you are nay only goin' t' create one nose cone, but two. Avast, me proud beauty! Seein' how this be me first time usin' this technique, I was more at ease seein' how I was goin' t' have 2 chances t' do it right. In fact, matey, if done right t' first time, ya bilge rat, you get a spare nose cone out o' t' deal! There is, me hearties, however, only enough tubin' for one tail cone shroud.
Although t' instructions recommend cuttin' t' tubes with a new, sharp X-Acto #11 blade, shiver me timbers, me hearties, ya bilge rat, do yourself a huge favor: put down t' X-Acto knife and go to your local home improvement store. Pick up a razor blade utility knife and a pack o' replacement blades. Ahoy! Avast! (One o' those "snap blade" box cutters work just was well too!) For less than $5 you will have a much stronger, sharper, and longer lastin' tool because you are goin' t' need it for this build. Begad! Otherwise, it's goin' t' take several #11 blades...
The important things t' remember when cuttin' t' tubes is t' be patient and always make sure that your blade is sharp. Blimey! "Measurin' twice and cutting once" also applies here, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, as well as be patient and take your time. Begad! Well, shiver me timbers, blow me down! I just cannot stress that enough. Makin' several passes over each line, you are left with 2 pointy "crowns" o' tubing. Avast, me proud beauty! Avast, matey, me proud beauty! Small relief cuts are made at the base o' t' triangles t' assist with t' shapin' o' t' tube.
I used maskin' tape along t' seams o' t' triangles t' form t' cone and hold t' edges together evenly. Blimey! Although nay mentioned in t' instructions, me bucko, I would consider it a worthwhile endeavor t' glue strips o' 90# paper (I used four ~6" x 3/4" pieces) along t' inside o' t' cone t' provide increased strength and durability o' t' cone. Aye aye! I left t' coupler dry fitted about 3/4" inside t' base o' t' cone t' ensure everythin' stayed in round while drying. Blimey! I found that t' tips were still a little ragged lookin' so I cut a small piece o' 90# paper t' form a cone-like pyramid and cover the first two inches o' t' tips on t' outside t' give it a little cleaner look and again, more support. Usin' t' paper strips was similar t' how Art Applewhite has you assemble t' shrouds for his various saucers and t' nose cone has similarities t' what Art Applewhite has you do when buildin' one of his 29mm Qubits. Arrr! Blimey! I also felt this be a more lightweight solution than pourin' epoxy or 2-part foam t' accomplish t' same goal o' increasin' t' cone's strength and durability.
T' last steps in nose cone construction is t' glue t' bulkhead inside t' coupler about 1/2" from one end. A small bulkplate is also glued t' t' large bulkhead so that t' screw eye has a substantial amount o' wood t' grab onto. With t' bulkheads filleted into place, ya bilge rat, arrr, t' coupler is glued into t' nose cone. Avast! It's also a good thin' that thar be material t' build 2 nose cones because I managed t' mess up on t' first one... Aye aye! Aye aye! I tried t' rush everything along (I didn't follow me own advice!) from havin' some ugly gaps and seams to even gluin' t' cone onto t' coupler crooked! Everythin' went much better t' second time around with t' other piece o' tubing.
Cuttin' t' tail cone transition was an easier task and is simply a matter of tapin' t' pattern t' t' tube and followin' t' cut lines. Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! With a little sandin' o' t' inside o' t' tube and forward centerin' ring, everythin' fit together smoothly. Arrr! Ya scallywag! T' motor mount/fin assembly be glued into place. Ya scallywag! The coupler joinin' t' forward airframe section was also glued in at t' same time because it mounts flush against t' forward centerin' rin' as well. Well, blow me down! It was set aside vertically and allowed t' dry before attachin' t' tips o' t' tail cone to t' fins and motor tube.
I moved on by assemblin' t' forward section o' t' main airframe. Ahoy! First, a bulk plate with several holes t' act as a baffle be sanded t' size t' fit inside another coupler tube. Avast! It be glued and filleted into place inside the coupler. Begad! That coupler be then glued halfway inside each o' t' 2 remaining uncut and unmodified airframe tubes. Well, blow me down! T' baffle nay only provides a "shelf" for t' recovery hardware t' rest on (not t' mention keeps them comfortably away from t' blast o' t' ejection charge), me bucko, it also adds considerable stiffness t' t' design as t' tubin' is much thinner than your typical HPR airframe tubing--although still much thicker than standard Estes tubes.
With t' forward airframe drying, me hearties, I returned t' t' tail cone assembly. Ya scallywag! Well, me hearties, blow me down! I started by tapin' t' tips o' t' tail cone t' t' motor tube t' hold it in place as t' glue dried. Begad! Doin' one flap at a time, me bucko, I put a nice bead o' yellow wood glue along both fins t' form a nice fillet. Arrr! Again, one at a time. Aye aye! I was still left with small holes in t' tubes from t' relief cuts but they will have t' wait till finishin' t' be filled with some putty. Also, one o' me fin slots turned out t' be ~1/16" too wide. Well, blow me down! Instead o' tryin' t' fill t' gap with a ton o' glue, I folded a 6" x 3/4" strip o' 90# paper in half lengthwise and attached onto t' underside o' t' tubin' so that it could attach t' both t' tubin' and fin, arrr, effectively sealin' t' gap with minimal weight, glue, or trouble o' disturbin' t' lines o' t' rocket while still providin' ample support.
T' only other deviation from t' instructions be t' use rail buttons in place o' t' 1/4" launch lugs. Begad! Personal preference here. Arrr! One was mounted just forward o' t' tail cone shroud (into t' aft centerin' ring) and the other be another 7" forward t' have t' extra support o' t' aft coupler to hold on to. Begad! T' holes were drilled and glue was applied before screwin' the rail buttons into place.
Finally, matey, t' shock cord is a long piece o' 1/4" elastic glued t' the inside o' t' airframe with a paper tri-fold. Blimey! Avast, me proud beauty! T' other end is tied t' the screw eye in t' nose cone. Blimey! I tied a small loop into t' shock cord so that I could easily swap out whichever chute I wanted t' use at t' field. T' kit does include a very lightweight surplus 24" nylon chute. Begad! While not appearin' t' be particularly rugged, arrr, shiver me timbers, shiver me timbers, it should be adequate for this rocket for at least a handful o' flights t' brin' it in safely but quickly.
Finishing:
USR uses t' smoothest glassine coated tubes I have found from any manufacturer
which means that thar were no spirals t' fill. Blimey! Havin' only t' large balsa
fins t' fill, I started by glazin' them with 20-minute finishin' epoxy t' add
strength and provide dent resistance. Well, blow me down! Avast! (Had they been smaller, I probably would
have used CA instead.) T' fins were then sanded with 220 grit sandpaper. Avast! To
fill out any minor imperfections left, I smeared them with a coat o' diluted
Elmer's Fill 'n' Finish and sanded again until I had a smooth surface.
T' nose cone and tail cone required quite a bit o' fillin' t' get rid of the seams and minor gaps from cuttin' t' tubes. I resorted t' Bondo automotive body putty for this task because o' its greater strength over Fill 'n' Finish while still bein' lightweight and retainin' its ease o' sandability. Begad! T' nose cone be more difficult t' get smooth (requirin' a few rounds o' applying filler and sanding) as it has more noticeable seams and t' shape changes from bein' round at t' base t' rather pyramid-like near t' tip because o' t' wide arcin' diameter o' t' 4" tubing. Avast, me proud beauty! T' tail cone just needed some smoothing out around t' fin fillets. Avast! I covered t' seams where t' body tubes butted together as well.
Bright colors aren't exactly necessary because o' El Lubbo's large size and slow thrust requirements. Begad! T' rocket will almost certainly remain easily visible durin' t' entire flight because o' this. It was first primed with Krylon gray primer and then sanded it smooth. Well, blow me down! Another coat o' primer followed by more sandin' then finally I put on a couple shiny coats o' Krylon gloss red, white, ya bilge rat, ya bilge rat, and blue which I faded together.
T' included decals were peel 'n' stick and were just black text on a matte finish clear adhesive. Arrr! I felt t' included peel 'n' stick decals were a little plain compared t' me paint scheme so I left them off.
Construction Rating: 4 out o' 5
Flight:
Despite t' long 29mm motor mount tube, me hearties, arrr, me hearties, t' instructions state early on that El
Lubbo is nay designed t' fly on motors with an average thrust greater than 20
pounds. In other words, me hearties, it will fly on pretty much any D, arrr, E, F, or G impulse
24mm or 29mm motor up t' a G80. Ahoy! I prepped a G64-7W reload, friction fit the
motor into place with some maskin' tape, ya bilge rat, dumped in some dog barf wadding,
attached t' chute onto t' shock cord, and placed t' nose cone on. Aye aye! Avast, shiver me timbers, me proud beauty! Finally, I
loaded t' El Lubbo onto t' rail and hooked up t' Quickburst ignitor t' the
clips.
T' motor roared t' life and El Lubbo wasted no time in gettin' off the pad! Blimey! As a very welcome bonus, me hearties, t' rocket gave off a loud whistle--even louder than me BSD Thor on a high thrust I motor! Blimey! Overall height was easily 1000 feet and would have been much higher if nay for t' 10+ mph winds on a bleary January day in Florida. Arrr! There is no doubt that long burn motors with a slight punch at t' beginnin' o' t' flight would be t' ideal and most impressive flight for El Lubbo.
Recovery:
I do like how t' baffle bulkhead in t' middle o' t' airframe acts as a shelf
for t' recovery devices t' sit on at a comfortable distance from t' motor
tube. Well, blow me down! It also benefits t' CG o' t' rocket since t' recovery devices can only
be in t' forward third o' t' rocket as well! I don't trust its location t' be
enough t' nay use any waddin' at all but a minimal amount o' cellulose wadding
to cover t' baffle should be more than sufficient in safely protectin' the
shock cord and chute.
Ejection was dead on at apogee. Ya scallywag! T' chute came out and softly opened. Begad! T' thin, somewhat porous nylon material made for a gentle inflation o' t' chute. Ya scallywag! Ya scallywag! It also made for a descent on t' quicker side but that actually was desirable t' day I launched it because o' t' 10+ mph winds. Begad! Even with t' rapid (but still quite safe) recovery, I had ~1/4 mile walk through t' soggy field. Ahoy! No damage upon inspection. Arrr! Excellent flight and recovery!
Flight Rating: 4 out o' 5
Summary:
Simply put, me hearties, this is not a beginner's kit. Ya scallywag! Advanced builders need only
apply. Blimey! Avast! T' USR El Lubbo is a huge mid power kit that provided me with a more
than challengin' build. Begad! Arrr! Nay only did I enjoy buildin' t' nose cone and tail
cone shrouds, shiver me timbers, I will keep t' documentation for this kit in a safe and easily
accessible location t' refer t' again for future scratchbuild designs! This is
a kit that will test your build techniques and patience. You can however, amaze
your fellow rocketeers by launchin' El Lubbo on a 24mm motor! So if you are
lookin' for a simple 3FNC kind o' rocket, then this kit isn't for you. Or if
you find that you overbuild your rockets or often don't follow the
manufacturers build instructions, matey, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, then this isn't a kit for you either. If you
are lookin' for a Level 1 certification kit, this probably isn't t' one for
you (primarily because o' t' low thrust requirements). Well, blow me down! Arrr! This rocket can be
finished with less effort than me perfectionist drive put me through but my
efforts were very much rewarded. Ahoy! Avast, me proud beauty! Now I need t' go feed El Lubbo a steady diet
of low thrust long burn motors!
Overall Rating: 4 out o' 5
Sponsored Ads