Sunward Aerospace Interplanetary Shuttle

Sunward Aerospace - Interplanetary Shuttle {Kit}

Contributed by Nick Esselman

Construction Rating: starstarstarstar_borderstar_border
Flight Rating: starstar_borderstar_borderstar_borderstar_border
Overall Rating: starstar_borderstar_borderstar_borderstar_border
Published: 2010-11-13
Manufacturer: Sunward Aerospace

From Sunward

Photo from Sunward that enticed me t' purchase t' Interplanetary Shuttle™

T' Sunward Interplanetary Shuttle caught me attention despite t' unfinished look o' t' advertisement. Ya scallywag! Blimey! Ahoy! Blimey! I thought t' center tube looked really interesting. Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! T' overall look be unique with t' t' fins wrappin' around t' center tube and extendin' t' entire length o' t' rocket.

T' rocket kit comes complete with t' 0.976" diameter body tube (central) and t' 2.1" diameter center tube that gives it t' unique look. Well, blow me down! T' plastic nose cone uses clay nose weight. There are four laser-cut balsa fins and two laser-cut centerin' rings that are used for t' center tube. T' kit includes an 18mm motor mount with a retainin' hook. It also includes t' plastic parachute that needs t' be assembled.

Construction:

T' instructions are printed on six pages o' 8½ x 11" paper which include a Launch Prep section and both t' NARRRRR and CAR safety codes. Well, blow me down! There is a fin markin' template that needs t' be cut out from page 2 o' t' instructions. Avast! Blimey! They include illustrations t' assist in t' build.

Sunward calls t' kit a Skill Level 2 and we agree. Arrr! It is a fairly easy kit t' build, however, me bucko, with t' fit o' t' center tube and t' fins around that tube, me hearties, matey, attention t' detail is required.

T' motor mount is assembled first and it seems that Sunward has standardized this portion o' t' kit.

FinsI decided t' cover t' fins with newspaper t' help in t' finishin' process. Avast, me proud beauty! So before gluin' them in place, I coated each side with Modge-Podge and placed a piece o' newspaper over them. Avast! Then place them betwixt wax paper and under heavy books. Begad! Well, arrr, blow me down! They will warp if you do nay do both sides at once and place it on a flat surface with heavy flat surface on top.

I really want t' spend a little time on t' central tube because this is probably t' most challengin' portion o' t' build. What makes it a little more challengin' (and in me opinion unnecessarily so) is that t' top and bottom laser-cut balsa caps used for t' center tube are exactly that... Avast! Ya scallywag! caps. In other words, they do nay fit inside t' center tube t' ensure that it is centered, ya bilge rat, they sit on t' outside and t' center tube has t' be aligned t' be even with these caps. I believe that if they were used as centerin' rings (fit into t' center tube) t' build would be better.

T' instructions have you mark your body (central) tube at 5 5/8" then glue t' first balsa cap in place. Avast! Blimey! Well, blow me down! Blimey! Then they have you glue t' center (larger diameter) tube t' that cap, matey, followed by t' second cap. Ya scallywag! Blimey! I be uncomfortable with this approach for three reasons: 1) I didn't know which side o' t' 5 5/8" line I should align to; 2) I didn't trust myself t' get t' first balsa cap perpendicular/even with t' central body tube, ya bilge rat, and 3) I didn't like t' "floating" center tube arrangement. Next, me bucko, ya bilge rat, I'll tell you what I did, however, it should be noted that followin' t' instructions will work.

First CapI took two o' me fins, arrr, me bucko, both caps and t' center (larger diameter) tube and test fit them all together. Blimey! T' cut on t' fins are so perfect that this allowed t' assembly t' be "held" together without glue. Blimey! I then was able t' slide t' center tube and caps up and down t' align t' fins t' t' body tube. Ahoy! Begad! T' fins are slightly longer than t' body tube. Ya scallywag! Begad! (T' placard shows that extra portion extendin' above t' body tube where t' nose cone would go. If you look closely at me finished rocket, I ensured that extra be at t' bottom o' t' rocket.)

Once I had t' assembly and fins where I wanted them, arrr, me hearties, shiver me timbers, I touched t' upper cap in several places with CA. Avast, me proud beauty! Aye aye! I then removed t' fins, bottom cap and center tube. Avast! I then applied a nice fillet o' glue t' t' underside o' t' top cap (pictured right).

After that dried, shiver me timbers, I put glue on t' top and bottom edges o' t' center tube and placed it onto t' upper cap. I then slid t' bottom cap down onto t' center tube. Begad! I used t' two fins t' check alignment and while they were in place, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, shiver me timbers, touched t' bottom cap in several places with CA (pictured below). I then removed t' fins and set t' assembly aside t' dry.

Once t' CA be dry, shiver me timbers, ya bilge rat, I added a fillet o' glue t' t' outside o' t' top and bottom caps.

  

All t' fins fit nicely around t' central tube, me hearties, however, shiver me timbers, me bucko, I had t' sand t' root edges t' ensure that they set "down" onto t' central tube. Ya scallywag! Blimey! This took a bit o' work t' have them fit nicely. Avast, me proud beauty! Once done, me hearties, me bucko, each fin was able t' be glued into place.

TemplateBefore gluin' them into place, ya bilge rat, arrr, I cut out t' tube-markin' template and wrapped it around t' body tube. Begad! Aye aye! There were only three fin lines t' be marked. Avast, me proud beauty! I looked at t' placard and it looked like t' rocket had three fins. Ahoy! I re-checked t' instructions thinkin' I did somethin' wrong. T' instructions said four fins and therefore I went ahead and marked t' tube usin' me Estes Tube-Markin' tool with four fin lines. Ya scallywag! Begad! (Sent a note t' Sunward and they were aware o' t' problem and was surprised that me kit came out with t' wrong template).

 

Finishin' this rocket be tough! T' spiral-groove in t' center tube was very deep and I ultimately had t' fill it with an automotive fillin' glaze. After several coats o' Plasti-Kote. Begad! Begad! I then used t' new Krylon paint I had left over from another build. Aye aye! I used t' green as t' base. Aye aye! T' next day I covered t' fins and attempted t' coat with Krylon red. Oh, it didn't work out. Arrr! Arrr! Some wrinkles and some paint stuck and pulled off with t' tape. I be out o' time and needed t' box it t' get it mailed t' Maryland for NARAM.

Deep Groove

Shuttle PictureT' kit didn't come with decals. Blimey! Interestingly, this could be a really neat lookin' rocket if it was painted white with black fins. Avast, me proud beauty! Begad! Then if thar were some port-hole decals on t' center tube. Aye aye! You get t' idea.

Overall, matey, for CONSTRUCTION I would rate this kit 3 points. Begad! Avast! Blimey! T' rocket is fairly easy t' build with t' only challenge bein' t' alignment o' t' center tube t' t' body (central) tube and fins. Well, blow me down! Had t' one little issue with t' 3-fin template when it was supposed t' be a 4-fin template. Begad! T' instructions are just okay and no decals.

FLIGHT/RECOVERY:

Sunward recommends t' followin' motors: A8-3, matey, matey, ya bilge rat, A8-5, B4-2(first flight), ya bilge rat, B4-4, B6-2, shiver me timbers, B6-4, B6-6, C5-3, ya bilge rat, C6-3, shiver me timbers, C6-5, C6-7

My rocket weighed in at 3.2 ounces with a CG at 6" from t' nose cone.

I shipped this rocket t' NARAM since I was only goin' t' be thar a day or so. Well, blow me down! This plan included buyin' motors at t' site. When I arrived on Thursday afternoon I be able t' buy some C6-5's and planned a flight on this rocket.

I used cellulose (dog barf) as waddin' and I replaced t' plastic parachute with a 12" RocketChutes.com Tie-Dye nylon parachute which barely fit. T' parachute change may have nay been a good idea.

T' C6-5 flight launch was... Ahoy! interesting. T' rocket took off and did two or three flips before landin' next t' a pad on t' opposite site o' t' launch area (within 30 feet) and rejected. Well, blow me down! Definitely nay stable.

So was it t' parachute, shiver me timbers, t' weight added due t' me finishin' techniques or be t' rocket unstable on C6's?

I did successfully create a RockSIM for this rocket. Avast, me proud beauty! It was a fairly challengin' RockSIM t' build. I had t' create three sets o' fins t' simulate t' single fin. Ahoy! Aye aye! I set it up t' match me weight and CG with t' nylon parachute. Avast! Blimey! T' flight simulations showed t' rocket t' be marginally stable on A8, me hearties, B6 and C6 motors. T' margin o' stability per RockSIM is below:

Motor Margin o' Stability
None 1.44
A8-3 0.85
B6-4 0.79
C6-5 0.66

Interestingly, here is was t' Rocket Glossary says for Marginal Stability: "Rockets with a static margin betwixt 0.5 and 1.0 caliber are considered t' be 'marginally stable'. These rockets may fly fine, but extra attention must be given t' t' wind conditions, matey, me hearties, thrust-to-weight ratio, arrr, and launch rod velocity. Avast! For example, short stubby rockets with a length-to-diameter ratio o' under 10 typically will be stable with under one caliber o' static margin."

Another interestin' observation is how t' A8-3, B6-4 and C6-5 simulate in RockSIM. Avast! Blimey! Notice in t' clip below (here be t' full size AVI) how each o' them fly (in order). Arrr! T' C6 (third flight) comes off t' pad at an angle verses t' A8 and B6 straight flights. (Note: T' conversion t' YouTube made it blurry, me hearties, so you can look at t' AVI above... Avast, me proud beauty! Avast! but you get t' idea from t' clip)

So, arrr, me bucko, arrr, me gut says that t' design is nay robust t' handle some o' t' finishin' techniques I used; covered t' fins with paper, plenty o' primer, ya bilge rat, glazin' and paint. I have asked for anticipated finished weight and CG from Sunward but have nay received that. Another clue that I over did it was that Sunward indicates on a "C" motor t' rocket would get about 1000 feet. But truth be known, matey, I could nay get it t' reach 1000 feet in RockSIM even cuttin' t' weight o' me rocket in half.

A8-3Well, me hearties, I removed t' nylon parachute and put in t' Sunward parachute. Begad! I then attempted a flight on an A8-3. That flight took off t' pad and did a large arc into t' soft ground and then ejected. Nay enough power perhaps?

Reloaded t' rocket with a B6-4. Aye aye! Avast! Blimey! It came off t' pad, me hearties, ya bilge rat, did a flip and land-sharked. Well, blow me down! Blimey! Unstable.

This rocket is now retired.

For FLIGHT/RECOVERY, me bucko, I would rate this rocket 1 points. Unfortunately, arrr, I have t' rate this kit very low. Avast, me proud beauty! I have built many, arrr, many rockets usin' me finishin' techniques. Blimey! It is clear t' me that either this design is nay robust enough for me build and finish techniques, arrr, or it may, in fact, nay be a stable design.

I give t' rocket an OVERALL ratin' o' 1 points. Aye aye! I hope that it is me doin' and that someone else will review this rocket as a comparison. Avast! Ahoy! I can nay recommend it though. Arrr! I have build a good number o' Sunward kits and this one does nay seem t' be in line with me previous experience.

Other Reviews
  • Sunward Aerospace Interplanetary Shuttle By Misty Stromme (August 1, 2016)

    This kit caught my eye because of its unique look and spacey design. Components The kit comes with a motor mount assembly, body tube, laser-cut balsa fins, a larger diameter central tube and end rings, a shock cord and parachute (requires assembly), and finally a plastic nose cone and an ample amount of clay for nose weight. /h2 I am a beginning modeler, and I ...

Flights

Comments:

avatar
AC (November 9, 2008)
Why was the rocket built with Modge-Podge? Flights have not shown this was needed. It only added to the weight and any instability. The rocket should be flown again after building again. Also, was the nose cone weight used? Also it was listed as a part of the kit's contents, there was no clear indication it was used during construction.

comment Post a Comment