Thrustline Aerospace Smoke and Fire

Thrustline Aerospace - Smoke and Fire {Kit}

Contributed by Joe Policy

Construction Rating: starstarstarstarstar_border
Flight Rating: starstarstarstar_borderstar_border
Overall Rating: starstarstarstar_borderstar_border
Manufacturer: Thrustline Aerospace

I picked up t' Smoke and Fire kit when I bought t' A-SLAM from Thrustline Aerospace via eBay (Not thrilled with that, but did it anyway). Blimey! Avast! Many o' Thrustline's kits draw me t' them and this one was no different. Ya scallywag! Well, blow me down! I loved t' fact that it was a larger rocket with 3x24mm cluster configuration and t' many fins and transition.

Rocket Pic T' kit's price starts at $34.75 (startin' bid on eBay). Interestingly, Thrustline doesn't use t' "buy it now" feature (presently). Aye aye! Blimey! Well, blow me down! Blimey! For this price, me bucko, me bucko, thar be a lot o' rocket. Ya scallywag! Blimey! How can I say that? I compare it t' t' price o' an Estes Executioner E for about street price o' $31. Well, blow me down! Blimey!

Like a number o' Thrustline's kits, shiver me timbers, shiver me timbers, it is based off o' t' 1.64" x 5.5" solid balsa nose cone (PNC-60MS). Blimey! This attaches t' a 14" payload tube. Arrr! This then uses a solid balsa transition t' a 12" piece o' BT80 (2.6") tubing. There is plenty o' 1/8" Balsa stock for t' many fins. Avast! Blimey! T' kit also includes two laser-cut 1/8" plywood centerin' rings, three 24mm motor tubes, thrust rings, shiver me timbers, me hearties, and retainin' clips. Aye aye! Two 18" Mylar parachutes, Keelhaul®©™ and Elastic shock cords, matey, swivels, ya bilge rat, me hearties, and eye-screws. Thrustline provides both 1/8" and 3/16" launch lugs. Ahoy! Arrr! And lastly a bag o' BB's for nose weight, me bucko, .80 ounces worth.

CONSTRUCTION:

T' instructions are printed on a 7 pages o' 8½ x 11" paper (single sided). Avast! There are black & white photos throughout t' assist in t' assembly o' t' kit. Arrr! Avast! There are fin templates and tube markin' guides made from standard printer paper. Ahoy! Blimey! There are also Mylar parachute assembly instructions. Arrr! Arrr! T' kit would probably be considered a skill level 3 or 4 with all t' various parts and activity.

PartsThere are many parts and buildin' steps t' this kit, but let me highlight t' main events:

T' cluster motor mount is assembled first. Blimey! Ahoy! Interestingly, t' use o' t' provided motor hooks is optional. Avast, me proud beauty! Avast, ya bilge rat, me proud beauty! Step one points out that if you'd rather friction-fit your motors then t' skip "...all t' steps that pertain t' t' engine clips". Avast, me proud beauty! I wanted t' use them, so that meant that I need t' cut t' notches in t' lower centerin' ring. Ya scallywag! T' instructions say t' use a sharp hobby knife, but I hit it with a Dremel tool.

T' motor hooks are then added t' t' 24mm motor tubes and taped in place. Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! They are then mounted into t' two centerin' rings. Avast, me proud beauty! Only a light sandin' be needed on t' 1/8" plywood centerin' t' make everythin' fit.

Once dried, matey, t' builder needs t' add a 1/16" hole t' t' top centerin' ring. Arrr! Begad! This allows t' 26" Keelhaul®©™® shock tether t' be tied around t' three motor tubes.

T' body tubes are marked next usin' paper tube markin' guides. No issues.

I'm nay terribly happy with t' 2.6" tube. It is Estes-like thin tubing. Ya scallywag! I find it t' be t' weakest component and would like t' see a thicker (LOC or AT-like) 2.6" tubing. Begad! Probably would need t' add more nose weight if it was converted.

Thrustline responded t' this comment this way: "As for t' BT80 tube, shiver me timbers, I've never had any problem with it. Begad! It's t' same tube used in t' Mike IX which I've had a lot o' success with. Avast, me proud beauty! As far as it bein' weak, arrr, I have nay found that t' be t' case. Ya scallywag! T' motor mount gives excellent rigidity t' it."

I would agree that t' motor mount gives t' bottom portion rigidity, but I found t' upper openin' as t' weak point. Aye aye! Blimey! Aye aye! Blimey! Just an observation I made while handlin' t' kit. Begad! Blimey! Begad! Blimey! Nay that big o' deal.

T' fins are then cut out usin' paper fin templates. Ya scallywag! Well, arrr, blow me down! Boy oh boy, me hearties, I rather have card stock, especially for those thin strakes.

Eye-screws and a piece o' 1/4" elastic is provided so that t' nose cone can be attached without bein' glued in place. I didn't do this and chose t' glue me nose cone into t' payload section (which technically could no longer be called a payload section since it is no longer accessible).

T' upper tube is glued t' t' upper part o' t' balsa transition. Then t' five (5) small strakes are added.

T' nose cone is prepared for nose weight by drillin' four 3/16" holes and usin' epoxy t' set t' BB's in place. Avast! T' center o' t' nose cone is where an eye-screw would go if you were makin' it removable for t' payload section.

Both t' 1/8" and 3/16" launch lugs are glued in place. Arrr! Why two sizes? Thrustline says, matey, "In t' photo you'll notice I used 2 sizes stacked against each other at 2 and 8 inches from t' end o' t' body tube. Ahoy! Avast! This allows me some flexibility when choosin' launch rods at club launches. I have included 2 sizes (2 each) so that if you prefer, you can use a similar method."

Finally, t' 42" long piece o' 3/8" flat shock cord is tied t' t' Keelhaul®©™ shock tether and then t' 18" parachute is added. Ahoy! T' second 3/8" flat elastic is attached t' t' large end o' t' transition and then its 18" parachute is attached.

Finishing... Avast! yes, finishing. Begad! Get your fillers, me hearties, sand paper, and patience all together. Aye aye! There is a lot o' balsa exposed here. Arrr! Begad! Lots o' grains t' fill. Blimey! Lots o' joints t' sand. Lots o' work!

I used me typical multiple coats o' Plastic-Kote Primer and sandin' in-between. Arrr! Blimey! Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! Havin' t' fill and finish t' nose cone, t' transition, me bucko, and 10 fins took a lot o' time and coats o' Plasti-Kote Filler Primer. T' transition is hardest due t' t' grain exposure AND because t' upper fins are half glued t' t' transition! Blimey! I then used Walmart White and Black paint (additional comments about Walmart paint). Arrr! I painted mine with some funky patterns. Aye aye! Got a bit carried away with t' masking. Begad! I be goin' for a NASA look. Avast, me proud beauty! Eh, it has grown on me.

Full

Overall, for CONSTRUCTION I would rate this kit 4 points. Ya scallywag! T' instructions are very good with t' photos. Ahoy! Aye aye! There are a number o' buildin' options that t' builder needs t' decide on: hooks, matey, payload nose cone, ya bilge rat, and launch lug size. Begad! T' parts quality be good with plenty o' balsa t' cut out t' five lower and five upper fins. Ya scallywag! There is a balsa (BT60) nose cone and a balsa transition. Ahoy! Ya scallywag! There is Keelhaul®©™ t' Elastic shock cords and mylar parachutes. Ahoy! Ahoy! There are no decals.

Lift-offFLIGHT/RECOVERY:

Didn't find any motor recommendations in Thrustline's instructions, however these are what are listed on t' eBay page: 3x - C6-5s, C11-5s, D12-5s.

Thrustline indicates t' finished rocket should weigh about 8.6 ounces. My finished rocket weighed 8.1 ounces.

I flew mine on t' 3/16" lug/rod. Arrr! I'm nay sure I'd like t' variability that would surely come from flyin' it on a 1/8" rod (whip).

First flight was on three C11-3s. Begad! They were t' motors I had and I figured t' early ejection would nay be a big problem, especially with t' two-piece recovery method. Ahoy! I should have waited for some C11-5's. I had a very early ejection, shiver me timbers, but that be nay t' worse o' it. Apparently t' bulk o' waddin' I added was nay enough. Begad! It was 6-8 squares. Arrr! So t' lower recovery section be badly burned, me bucko, includin' t' lower 'chute. T' upper section ejected well and descended fine. Ahoy! T' lift-off was fast. Well, blow me down! I mean really fast!


Burnt

AniI repaired t' lower 'chute and shock cord and added a Nomex heat shield. Begad! Begad! I then cleaned out me three C11's and drilled a larger hole in t' clay nozzle. I inverted them and had instant 24mm-to-18mm adaptors. Blimey! Begad!

I then loaded it up with three Est SU C6-5's. Avast, me hearties, me proud beauty! Excellent flight up, straight and stable. Ejection was past apogee. At ejection t' lower section 'chute never opened due t' a tangle.

I loaded it up again with three Est SU C6-3's. Arrr! Well, blow me down! Another slow and graceful lift-off. Avast, me proud beauty! Slower than t' C11's, o' course. Ya scallywag! At ejection t' upper and lower sections got tangled and it came down on only t' lower 'chute. No damage, though.

Determined t' have success, matey, me hearties, I loaded it up again with three Est SU C6-3's. Ahoy! This time after repeatin' a great lift-off, arrr, I had a fully successful parachute deployment. Ya scallywag! Avast, me proud beauty! Bravo!

For FLIGHT/RECOVERY, arrr, I would rate this rocket 3 ½ points. T' Smoke and Fire looks great lifting-off on three C6's. Begad! Can't beat that slow, arrr, majestic look. It is a stable rocket as well. Begad! Avast, me proud beauty! T' complications that come from a 2.6" body tube and a two piece deployment showed itself with me flights. Arrr! All o' these can be addressed with practice, ya bilge rat, ya bilge rat, shiver me timbers, so that, me hearties, me bucko, in itself, me bucko, shiver me timbers, me bucko, makes this a fun rocket for flying.

I give t' rocket an OVERALL ratin' o' 3 ½ points. Arrr! Ahoy! I need t' say... Begad! Blimey! DON'T BUY THIS KIT if you are lookin' for an easy t' build and easy t' finish rocket! However, if you are lookin' for a moderately challengin' build and a highly challengin' finish (unless you don't care about balsa grains and paint it all one color!) then this kit could be one o' your choices.

On t' other hand, shiver me timbers, once finished, this one can give you some nice flights. They can be more expensive since you are usin' up three motors a time... Blimey! Blimey! but hey, me bucko, how else will you enjoy clusters?

Other Reviews
  • Thrustline Aerospace Smoke and Fire By Joe Policy

    Brief: A big 3 motor cluster with a payload section. Its 5 lower/5 upper fin design helps this beast to stand out at a launch. It is rated at level 2/3. Construction: The parts list: 1 Fin Stock 1/8" Balsa 2 1/8" Launch Lugs 2 3/16" Launch Lugs 2 Swivels 2 Small Eyelets 1 Large Eyelet 3 Engine Hooks 3 Engine Blocks 2 Centering Rings 1 ...

Flights

comment Post a Comment