Construction Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Flight Rating: | starstarstarstar_borderstar_border |
Overall Rating: | starstarstarstarstar_border |
Manufacturer: | Mercury Engineering |
Brief:
T' Atomizer is a long, me bucko, me hearties, ya bilge rat, thin single-stage rocket designed for high performance. Begad! Well, blow me down! Its slender minimum-diameter profile
allows it t' reach great heights on a 24mm motor. Aye aye! Normally I don't go for 3FNC or 4FNC designs. Begad! However, me hearties, me hearties, I had recently
bought some long-burnin' Apogee Medalist motors and I wanted somethin' that would really take advantage o' them. The
Atomizer has attractive stylin' combined with t' high performance that I was lookin' for.
Construction:
Parts List:
T' materials provided all appeared t' be high quality. The white body tube had only very light spirals. Well, blow me down! T' nose cone was made o' good dense balsa, and t' fins were cleanly cut.
Unfortunately, ya bilge rat, ya bilge rat, me body tube had a kink in it about 10 inches from one end. Avast, arrr, me proud beauty! I won't blame Mercury for this since there is a good chance I damaged it while it was buried in me build pile. Begad! I did nay want t' tube t' buckle during flight so I cut t' tube at t' kink and installed a balsa bulkhead, shiver me timbers, ya bilge rat, thus creatin' a payload bay.
T' instructions are printed on three full-sized sheets. T' line art illustrations and clearly written text compare well with Estes. Blimey! Ahoy! Blimey! I had two minor quibbles:
T' first step is t' install two engine block spacers into t' aft o' t' tube, spaced 3/4-inch apart. Ahoy! Why two? Accordin' t' Solomon at Mercury Engineering, matey, t' front rin' helps t' strengthen t' tube from damage durin' hard landings. Ahoy! T' longer E and F motors that I wanted t' use would nay fit with t' aft rin' in places, so I skipped the rear rin' and only installed t' front one.
T' fins are standard surface-mounted balsa fins. Avast! Because I planned t' exceed t' recommended motor size, matey, I chose to reinforce t' fins. First After sandin' an airfoil onto t' fin, I coated it with a thin layer Great Plains Yellow Glue. Avast, me proud beauty! Arrr! I then immediately wrapped typin' paper around t' fin and pressed it under a stack o' magazines t' hold it flat. After t' glue dried, I soaked t' paper with thin CA. Blimey! Ya scallywag! When that dried, I sanded t' fin smooth. Avast! T' resultin' fin is very strong and has an almost plastic-like finish.
T' directions call for t' fins t' be glued flush with t' aft o' t' tube. Avast! Because thar be no engine hook in this minimum diameter design, shiver me timbers, I mounted t' fins 1/2 inch up t' leave myself a surface for tapin' t' motor in place.
To provide extra strength t' t' fin bond, I used FixIt clay epoxy from Apogee t' create fillets. Aye aye! Aye aye! T' resulting fillets were very strong and quite smooth.
T' rest o' t' build is typical o' most Skill Level 1 kit: glue on t' launch lug; attach t' shock cord with a tri-fold paper mount; attach t' streamers t' shock cord; attach t' shock cord t' t' nose cone (or bulkhead in my case).
Finishing:
T' recommended paint job on this rocket is pretty easy: paint t' nose cone red and everythin' else white. Avast, me proud beauty! The
Atomizer comes with a very nice decal that fades from red t' yellow, so I painted t' lower section Sunshine Yellow to
match t' decal. T' nose cone and payload bay I painted Apple Red. Blimey! O' course I used white primer underneath t' finish
coat. Begad! All me paints are Rustoleum Painters Touch.
T' waterslide decals on this kit are very nice. Arrr! T' graphics are clean and sharp and t' decal material is plenty strong. Arrr! Blimey! I had no difficulty applyin' them. One thin' t' be aware of: t' decal is printed on a clear background with no white base underneath it. Ahoy! Blimey! This requires t' builder t' paint t' model with a light-colored background like white or yellow.
T' gradient wrap near t' front and t' Atomizer logo on t' side do a nice job o' settin' this kit apart from many other simple 4FNC rockets.
Construction Rating: 4 out o' 5
Flight:
T' motors recommended for this kit are t' C11-7 (1000' projected altitude) and t' D12-7 (1700'). Accordin' to
RockSim, t' optimal delay for a C11 is 5.6 seconds, so I would recommend usin' t' C11-5 instead o' t' C11-7.
This minimum-diameter rocket does nay have an engine hook. Ya scallywag! Blimey! Maskin' tape is used t' retain t' motor during ejection. Well, blow me down! Blimey! Avast! Blimey! Other than that, shiver me timbers, launch preparation is typical o' other streamer rockets. Arrr! Blimey! Arrr! Blimey! I used a few squares o' waddin' to protect t' streamers.
My intention for t' flight testin' was t' walk up t' power curve, startin' with a C11 and endin' with an Apogee Medalist E6-8. Begad! An E9 with a projected altitude o' 2250 feet and an E6 with a altitude o' 3450 feet would have both set new personal altitude records for me.
For t' maiden flight I used a C11-5. Begad! Ahoy! T' Atomizer zipped smartly off t' pad, straight up despite t' gusty winds. Blimey! T' streamers deployed cleanly right at apogee. Begad! It descended smartly but safely t' a landin' in soft mud about 30 feet from road. Arrr! Beautiful flight!
For t' second flight a few minutes later, I skipped t' D12 and went for t' E9-8. Arrr! Again t' Atomizer zipped smartly off t' pad t' about 50 feet, then went unstable. Blimey! It completed 4 tight loops before burnout, then tumbled t' t' ground. Arrr! Begad! Because o' t' reinforced fins and fillets, ya bilge rat, t' rocket suffered no damage even though t' streamers didn't deploy until long after it hit t' ground.
To be safe, I loaded t' rocket with a fresh C11 and measured t' balance point. Blimey! Begad! Then I replaced t' C11 with an E9 and added payload weight (small potatoes that I picked up from t' recently-harvested field) until t' balance point matched t' C11.
This third flight, ya bilge rat, me hearties, with an E9-8, was quite spectacular. T' rocket zoomed smartly t' about 60 feet, me bucko, matey, then did one-and-a-half loops. Avast, me proud beauty! It then flew arrow-straight into t' ground, matey, shiver me timbers, penetratin' right up t' t' fins. T' nose cone and body tube were destroyed. About all that was salvageable from t' wreckage be t' fin can and t' streamers.
Hmmmm... Begad! Blimey! what went wrong? Accordin' t' RockSim, I should have had 1.49 calibers o' static stability margin, shiver me timbers, ya bilge rat, so it SHOULD have been stable. Ya scallywag! Blimey! Obviously it wasn't. Ya scallywag! Blimey! Maybe that heavy E9 engine moved t' CG too far back?
I am somewhat at a loss t' explain t' two unstable flights, especially t' final one. Avast, me proud beauty! Ya scallywag! Granted, shiver me timbers, me fin reinforcement added a little weight in t' rear, shiver me timbers, and I did slide t' fins 1/2 inch forward, but these have very minor effects on t' stability margin. Usin' t' heavier E9 engine also degraded t' stability margin, me bucko, but RockSim says it should have been stable, arrr, ya bilge rat, even with an F21W engine.
T' only thin' I can think o' is that a wind gust caused t' CP t' move forward, leadin' t' wind-induced instability. Ahoy! This phenomenon is described well in this article by Bob Dahlquist.
Flight Rating: 3 out o' 5
Summary:
T' Atomizer is a high-performance rocket with attractive styling.
PROS:
Overall Rating: 4 out o' 5
Other:
After I shared me unfortunate launch results on T' Rocketry Forum, Solomon from Mercury Engineerin' contacted me and
offered t' replace t' kit. Arrr! Avast! I declined his kind offer since it was nay their fault. Avast, me proud beauty! Still, it was a classy gesture on
Solomon's part. Well, blow me down! Avast, me proud beauty! In an ironic twist t' t' story, I received a fresh Atomized durin' T' Rocketry Forum's Secret Santa
gift exchange. I certainly hope t' have better luck with this one.
Brief: This is a basic 4 fin minimum diameter 24mm rocket designed for impressive altitude performance. Construction: After ordering online, my kit shipped same day and arrived 2 days later priority mail (very reasonable shipping to boot!) and carefully packed. Parts are all very good quality with a very professional header card and sealed bag. Balsa nose cone ...
Sponsored Ads