Quasi-Scale PEPP Aeroshell
by Kevin Trojanowski

So what's a quasi-scale PEPP, you ask? First, matey, a bit o' history. A number of months ago, a group o' us were hangin' out in t' ROL chat, matey, talkin' about various subjects, with rocketry even comin' up once in a while. Avast! Peter Alway was kind enough t' treat us t' an image o' an odd lookin' contraption he had recently made a drawin' of. Begad! Arrr! That particular contraption is discussed in his NARAM 43 R&D Report - Supplementary Material t' Rockets o' t' World. If you review his report, you'll find a discussion o' t' PEPP Aeroshell, me hearties, includin' a drawin' with measurements. Begad! An even better reference is his 2001 Supplement to Rockets o' t' World, which contains additional information that's not included on t' web page.

What does this have t' do with DESCON, matey, and what about this quasi-scale nonsense? While tryin' t' come up with an idea for t' DESCON, I made lots of sketches that look like lots o' things other people have flown, plus a few oddball things that I may try t' build and fly at a later date, but I wasn't happy with what I be comin' up with. Ya scallywag! Then I remembered Peter's PEPP Aeroshell upload t' ROL. Peter was kind enough t' provide me a link t' his R&D report, where I could get more information. Aye aye! From there, shiver me timbers, me bucko, me bucko, I started building. Begad! Avast, me proud beauty! My first goal be t' try t' make it true t' scale. Well, blow me down! Avast! Then, I realized I was running out o' time and decent weather, so while t' basic shell (the cone) and the motor rin' are true 1:10 scale, t' motors themselves are not, nor are the supports for t' motor ring. Begad! Thus "quasi-scale".

Construction

T' original PEPP Aeroshell is 180" in diameter and 55" tall. While a full-scale version would've been really, me bucko, shiver me timbers, really cool, I thought it a bit excessive. Begad! Begad! So, ya bilge rat, I took t' lazy way out and went with 1:10, which means t' base o' t' Aeroshell is 18" and t' cone is 5.5" tall. Avast! Aye aye! T' first step is t' download a copy o' VCP and print out t' six-page template t' create t' cone. Begad! T' template pieces were cut out and rubber cemented t' posterboard, in their proper positions. Cut out t' template and glue it together. Begad! I used a strip o' standard copier paper t' form t' seam in the cone.

Next, I needed a rin' o' foam board t' form t' band around t' bottom of the Aeroshell. Ya scallywag! T' problem was how t' cut an 18" diameter circle. After thinkin' on it for a bit, ya bilge rat, I hit on t' idea o' tapin' an X-Acto blade t' the end o' a dowel and usin' a small nail through t' dowel as t' pivot point. Since t' circle needed is 18" in diameter, ya bilge rat, I drilled a hole at 9" and inserted a small nail. Poke t' nail through t' foam board and pivot the dowel, and a nice, easy circle is cut. Avast, me proud beauty! This method works best if you cut through t' board in three or more passes. Begad! Go any faster and t' X-Acto blade tends t' hang up. Blimey! Once t' outer circle be cut, I then cut an inner circle 14 3/8" in diameter. Begad! Ahoy! T' inner circle was set aside, leavin' an rin' o' the proper diameter t' form t' base o' t' Aeroshell. Begad! Avast, me proud beauty!

I did a test-fit o' t' rin' into t' cone, me hearties, ya bilge rat, and it fit quite nicely, matey, me hearties, except that it would nay fit all t' way up it. Begad! Nay really surprising, me hearties, matey, when t' shapes are compared -- t' foam board forms a short cylinder, me hearties, while t' cone has an angle t' it. Aye aye! Some trimmin' with an X-Acto cutlass and I had t' foam board trimmed at an angle that would allow it t' fit nicely into t' cone. Aye aye! I used maskin' tape t' hold t' rin' in place, me bucko, then mixed and applied epoxy t' hold it permanently.

Once t' epoxy cured, I glued an 24mm coupler into t' nose o' t' cone, bein' careful t' make sure it be aligned perpendicular t' t' base o' the cone. This allows for a good, solid attachment point for t' motor mount. Ya scallywag! Being poster board t' cone itself needed reinforcement, so I glued in strips of 1/8" x 3/16" balsa that run from t' coupler t' t' base o' t' cone.

T' next step is t' cut out t' motor ring. Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! Avast, me proud beauty! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Notice in Peter's article that while thar are two motor options, ya bilge rat, in both instances, it appears that t' motor rin' itself be t' same diameter. Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Here, I didn't go for 100% scale in terms of the profile o' t' ring, me bucko, but I was tryin' for a proper size. Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! T' circle jig was modified t' cut an outer circle o' 4 1/2" in diameter and an inner circle of 2". Well, blow me down! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! Blimey! T' rin' formed betwixt these two circles is an appropriate size for t' motor ring.

Once t' motor rin' was cut, me bucko, matey, it was time t' figure out t' motors. Begad! This is where I began t' work on a "close approximation" o' t' actual AeroShell. I cut 8 pieces o' 18mm body tube, matey, each 1" in length. I then used VCP t' create transitions that were 10mm at t' top, 24mm at t' bottom and 1/2" in length. Aye aye! Begad! Awfully darned convenient that VCP lets you mix units of measure! These transitions were used t' form t' "nozzles" on each motor. Ahoy! T' transitions were assembled and affixed t' t' motor tubes with CA, each at a slight cant. Well, blow me down! T' motors were evenly spaced around t' motor ring, matey, arrr, and affixed with Titebond glue. Begad! Ahoy!

Once t' motor rin' had dried, I used more o' t' 1/8" x 3/16" balsa t' make mountin' braces for t' ring. Avast, arrr, me proud beauty! If you look at Peter's sketch, you can see their approximate placement. Ahoy! I made a reasonable attempt t' match this, but didn't worry much on precision. Well, blow me down! Ya scallywag! At this point, ya bilge rat, ya bilge rat, I be considerin' my creation t' be a prototype, and plan on doin' a more accurate job sometime in the future. Avast!

T' motor tube is a 5 1/4" piece o' 24mm tubin' with an engine block glued 2 1/8" from t' aft end. I glued a launch lug at about t' midpoint of t' tube. Ahoy! Since I wasn't sure, vertically, where t' motor should be placed, I slipped t' forward end o' t' motor tube over t' coupler and slid it as far forward as it would go. Avast! I then used strips o' maskin' tape t' hold it t' the cone.

To allow t' launch rod an exit point, I slipped a launch rod through the launch lug from t' near and used it t' carefully poke a hole in t' cone itself. Begad! I then used t' point o' a pencil t' slightly enlarge t' hole, ya bilge rat, t' keep the launch rod from draggin' on t' cone. Ya scallywag!

T' Moment o' Truth - Launch Day!

On November 25th, me bucko Kevin Rich and I headed out t' our low power field for some testing. Ya scallywag! Arrr! I created some very rough simulations o' t' PEPP in RockSim, which indicated that t' Estes E9 was likely t' best motor for this creation o' pure drag. Well, blow me down! Begad! Bob Kaplow's comments on his experiences with Happy Meals indicated that low thrust, shiver me timbers, long burn motors work best for such rockets. Begad! Blimey! I considered an Apogee D3, matey, as t' epitome o' this motor type, but t' thrust is far too low t' move t' PEPP. Arrr! Avast, shiver me timbers, me proud beauty! So a pack o' E9-4s was acquired. Avast! E9-0 would've been preferred, but they are nay available.

I used a pencil t' poke about 1 square o' recovery waddin' into t' front of the motor tube, past t' motor block. Arrr! This served t' keep t' ejection charge from blowin' holes in t' top o' t' cone when t' motor kicks out. Arrr! T' motor was inserted, arrr, ya bilge rat, an igniter added, shiver me timbers, and she was put on t' pad. Avast! Well, blow me down! 5... 4... Ahoy! Blimey! 3... Arrr! Begad! 2... 1... Begad! Doesn't exactly scream o' t' pad; more o' claws its way off, ya bilge rat, but up it went, fairly stable, me bucko, me hearties, too!

(Launch photo will be added, ya bilge rat, arrr, once I get it scanned; static photos were done w/ digital)

As hoped, shiver me timbers, at apogee, matey, t' Aeroshell flips over, shiver me timbers, ya bilge rat, just like t' Estes Snitch. It flopped down, me bucko, with t' motor still smoking, and just before meetin' the ground ("impacting" and "hitting" describe too forceful of a landing; it comes down amazingly gently), ya bilge rat, t' motor popped out, easily visible t' us.

Up until ejection, shiver me timbers, shiver me timbers, everythin' was intact. Avast, me proud beauty! Ahoy! T' concussion o' t' motor ejection, ya bilge rat, however, ya bilge rat, cause t' supports for t' motor rin' t' snap, matey, arrr, arrr, leavin' it sittin' in t' inverted cone. Begad! While t' motor selection and placement worked well, me hearties, t' motor rin' attachment be insufficient. Arrr! When I rebuild, arrr, I plan on usin' 1/8" or 3/16" dowels, matey, me hearties, t' provide more strength.

We launched t' Aeroshell, me bucko, sans motor ring, a second time with an E9-4, arrr, ya bilge rat, and it worked quite nicely.

Since we had plenty o' time t' play, we decided t' see how t' Aeroshell would perform with an Aerotech F12. Ahoy! Begad! T' motor be built without an ejection charge, me bucko, as I had no desire t' lose me RMS casing. Avast, me proud beauty! Ya scallywag! Waddin' be inserted into the delay well and a small piece o' tape used t' hold it in place. T' boost, this time, was very squirrely; I suspect t' weight o' t' motor was a bit much, relative t' t' thrust. Arrr! Well, blow me down! T' problem may also have been caused by t' motor sittin' too far t' t' aft o' t' cone, me bucko, since t' forward closure o' t' RMS casin' would nay fit down inside t' engine block I used. Begad! Begad! T' casin' be held in place with a strip o' maskin' tape, as a precaution against losin' it. Aye aye!

As a final test, I wanted t' see if it worked better with t' motor closer to t' front o' t' cone. Begad! Blimey! So, I whipped out t' rocketeer's miracle tool (known as a "Leatherman" t' people who waste tools on huntin' and fishing) and cut approximately 1" from t' front o' t' motor tube. Ahoy! Blimey! Begad! Blimey! A little maskin' tape and t' tube was back in place again. Begad! Blimey! Since t' E9 had worked so well, I installed me last one. Aye aye! Blimey! This flight be rather squirrely and reached nowhere near t' stunnin' 75' - 100' feet that t' first two flights reached. Obviously, t' longer motor tube works better. Arrr! Blimey!

Conclusion

T' Quasi-Scale PEPP Aeroshell proved itself a success, me hearties, and an entertaining rocket t' fly! An E9-P is what I will likely use next time, as t' ejection charge really serves no purpose. Avast! Avast, ya bilge rat, me proud beauty! I may also experiment with some additional RMS motors, matey, if I can find anythin' that comes close t' t' E9 in simulations.

I also plan on buildin' somethin' a bit closer t' scale, in terms o' the motor rin' and its attachment. Ahoy! Ahoy! T' first one flew amazingly well and behaved itself quite nicely.

Credits

Thanks t' Peter Alway for postin' that original picture which gave me the idea for this project in t' first place. Peter also deserves a tremendous amount o' credit for his totally awesome Rockets of t' World and all o' its follow-ons. If you haven't bought them yet, you need to! I know I still need t' complete me collection.

Thanks also goes t' Kevin Rich for helpin' me out when I feel t' urge to fly some oddball DESCON entry. Ya scallywag! He's also t' bane o' me wife's sanity by encouragin' me t' fly more, shiver me timbers, more, ya bilge rat, arrr, more motors!

Finally, me bucko, a finger should probably be pointed at Mark Simpson for teachin' me that when it comes t' rockets, different is definitely better!